A food mill and a blender both turn solid food into something smoother, but they work in opposite ways and they suit different jobs. A food mill presses cooked food through a perforated disc, so skins, seeds, and fibers stay behind while the puree passes through. A blender spins a blade at high speed, so everything in the jar gets chopped and mixed together, skins and seeds included. If you make tomato sauce from fresh tomatoes, applesauce from unpeeled apples, or mashed potatoes with no lumps, the mill earns its place. If you make smoothies, frozen drinks, nut butter, or a quick soup from raw vegetables, the blender is the faster tool. This guide compares the two side by side, with five real models to show what each type can do.
- How a Food Mill Works
- How a Blender Works
- 1. Mirro 50024 Foley Stainless Steel Food Mill, 2-Quart
- 2. GEFU Flotte Lotte Stainless Steel Food Mill
- 3. Blendtec Classic 575 Blender
- 4. KitchenAid Diamond KSB1575 5-Speed Blender, Empire Red
- 5. Ninja BN801 Professional Plus Kitchen System
- How to Choose Between a Food Mill and a Blender
- FAQ
- Bottom Line
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases made through links in this article. This disclosure explains that relationship, and the product details below come from manufacturer and retailer listings.
How a Food Mill Works
A food mill is a hand-cranked tool with a bowl, a rotating blade, and one or more interchangeable discs. You load cooked food into the bowl and turn the crank. The blade sweeps the food across the disc, and the puree falls through the holes into a pot or bowl below. Skins, seeds, stems, and tough fibers stay in the bowl, so the result is smooth without any peeling or seeding first. That is the mill’s main advantage: it separates as it purees. A tomato sauce made in a mill has no skins and no seeds, and an applesauce made in a mill needs no peeling or coring.
The trade-off is effort and scope. A mill only handles cooked, soft food, so raw carrots, ice, and frozen fruit are out of reach. The cranking takes arm work, and the bowl holds a limited amount at a time, so large batches move slowly. Cleanup means washing the bowl, the blade, the disc, and the crank. A mill is a specialist tool, and it shines on the jobs it was built for.
How a Blender Works
A blender is a motorized jar with a spinning blade at the bottom. You load food, add liquid if needed, and the blade chops everything into a uniform mix. Nothing is separated, so the skins, seeds, and fiber stay in the drink or soup. That makes a blender the better choice for smoothies, where the fiber is part of the point, and for frozen drinks, where the blade crushes ice. A blender also handles raw food, so a soup can begin with raw vegetables and finish in the jar. Most blenders run through a batch in under a minute, and many jars are dishwasher safe.
The trade-off is texture and control. A blender cannot remove tomato skins or apple seeds, so a sauce made in a blender needs straining or peeling first. Thick mixtures can stall the blade unless liquid is added, and the motor adds noise and counter space. A blender is a generalist tool, and it covers far more jobs than a mill, but it cannot do the mill’s separating trick.
1. Mirro 50024 Foley Stainless Steel Food Mill, 2-Quart
The Mirro 50024 Foley is the classic rotary food mill, a design that has been in kitchens for decades. It holds 2 quarts in a stainless steel bowl and comes with multiple milling discs that cover mashing, straining, grating, and ricing, so one tool handles applesauce, tomato sauce, mashed potatoes, and baby food. Two hooks and a long handle hold the mill steady over a pot or bowl while you crank, and the body weighs about 1.9 pounds, so it is easy to lift and store. It is the budget pick on the food-mill side, and it suits cooks who want the traditional mill experience without a large outlay.
Specs: Type: rotary food mill; Capacity: 2 quarts; Material: stainless steel; Discs: multiple milling discs for mashing, straining, grating, and ricing; Design: two hooks and long handle for stability over a pot; Weight: about 1.9 pounds; Model: 50024 Foley; ASIN: B000LNUM8Q
This mill suits a cook who makes applesauce or tomato sauce a few times a season and wants skins and seeds removed in one pass. Confirm the listing is live before ordering, since verification here rests on retailer roundup links to the product page rather than a recent direct catalog crawl.
2. GEFU Flotte Lotte Stainless Steel Food Mill
The GEFU Flotte Lotte is a German-made stainless steel food mill with the same rotary design, built around a sturdy bowl and a smooth crank. It presses cooked vegetables and fruit through its disc to make silky purees, and it separates skins and seeds just as the Mirro does. The Flotte Lotte is known for a solid, well-balanced feel in the hand, and its stainless construction resists staining from tomato sauce and other acidic foods. It suits cooks who want a heavier, longer-lasting mill and who value build quality over the lowest cost.
Specs: Type: rotary food mill; Material: stainless steel; Design: classic rotary crank with perforated disc; Use: purees, sauces, soups, and baby food; Construction: stainless steel bowl and crank; ASIN: B00008WVB8
This mill suits a cook who mills food often and wants a durable tool that will last through many seasons of canning and sauce making. Confirm the listing is live before ordering, since verification here rests on retailer roundup links to the product page rather than a recent direct catalog crawl.
3. Blendtec Classic 575 Blender
The Blendtec Classic 575 is a professional-grade countertop blender with a 1560-watt motor, five speeds, and four pre-programmed cycles for smoothies, soups, and frozen drinks. Its WildSide+ jar holds 90 ounces, with a 36-ounce blending capacity, and the forged stainless steel blade is built to crush ice and frozen fruit. A self-cleaning cycle makes cleanup simple: add water and a drop of soap, run the cycle, and rinse. The touch controls are simple to read, and the compact base fits a standard counter.
Specs: Type: countertop blender; Power: 1560 watts; Speeds: 5, plus pulse; Presets: 4 pre-programmed cycles; Jar: WildSide+ jar, 90-ounce volume, 36-ounce blending capacity; Blade: forged stainless steel; Features: self-cleaning cycle; Model: C575A2301A-A1AP1D; ASIN: B00LADPFP6
This blender suits a cook who wants high power for frozen drinks and thick smoothies and who values the large jar for family-size batches. Confirm the listing is live before ordering, since the most recent catalog crawl of this listing showed it unavailable, and availability should be checked carefully.
4. KitchenAid Diamond KSB1575 5-Speed Blender, Empire Red
The KitchenAid Diamond KSB1575 is a 5-speed countertop blender with a 60-ounce diamond-shaped pitcher that pulls ingredients down toward the blade. It runs on an 804-watt motor, with five speeds plus pulse, and the touch-button controls cover stir, chop, mix, puree, and liquefy. The pitcher is BPA-free plastic, and the Empire Red finish matches other KitchenAid appliances. It is a mid-range blender that handles everyday smoothies, soups, and sauces without the bulk of a professional unit.
Specs: Type: countertop blender; Power: 804 watts; Speeds: 5, plus pulse; Jar: 60-ounce diamond pitcher, BPA-free plastic; Controls: touch-button, with stir, chop, mix, puree, and liquefy; Model: KSB1575CER; Color: Empire Red; ASIN: B00OCRGM0Y
This blender suits a cook who wants a reliable everyday blender for smoothies and soups and who likes the KitchenAid look on the counter. Confirm the listing is live before ordering, since the most recent catalog crawl of this listing is about 216 days old.
5. Ninja BN801 Professional Plus Kitchen System
The Ninja BN801 Professional Plus is a kitchen system built around a 1400-peak-watt motor base with Auto-iQ programs. It includes a 72-ounce Total Crushing pitcher for smoothies and frozen drinks, a 64-ounce food processor bowl for chopping and dough, and two 24-ounce single-serve cups with spout lids. The five Auto-iQ functions cover smoothie, ice crush, extract, chop, and dough, so one base replaces a blender, a food processor, and a personal blender. The stacked blade assembly in the pitcher crushes ice quickly, and the processor bowl handles dough and chopped vegetables.
Specs: Type: countertop blender kitchen system; Power: 1400 peak watts; Functions: 5 Auto-iQ programs, smoothie, ice crush, extract, chop, and dough; Pitcher: 72-ounce Total Crushing pitcher; Processor bowl: 64 ounces; Cups: two 24-ounce single-serve cups with spout lids; Model: BN801; ASIN: B08559K7CN
This system suits a cook who wants one base to cover blending, chopping, and dough, and who values the single-serve cups for weekday smoothies. Confirm the listing is live before ordering, since the most recent catalog crawl of this listing is about 264 days old, though a deal listing seen in late October 2026 suggests it remains available.
How to Choose Between a Food Mill and a Blender
Begin with the job. If you make tomato sauce, applesauce, or mashed potatoes from whole cooked produce and you want skins and seeds gone, the food mill is the right tool, and no blender can replace it. If you make smoothies, frozen drinks, nut butter, or raw-vegetable soups, the blender is the right tool, and a mill cannot handle those jobs at all.
Next, think about batch size and effort. A blender finishes a batch in under a minute with no arm work, so it wins on speed. A mill takes longer and needs cranking, but it saves the peeling, coring, and seeding work that a blender-based sauce would require. For a large canning session, the mill’s separation saves more time than the cranking costs.
Then look at the counter and the budget. A mill is small, quiet, and inexpensive, and it stores in a drawer or a cabinet shelf. A blender needs counter space, makes noise, and costs more, but it covers far more jobs. Many kitchens end up with both: the blender for daily smoothies and soups, the mill for the seasonal sauce and applesauce batches where texture matters most.
Finally, consider cleanup. A blender jar rinses out quickly, and many jars are dishwasher safe. A mill has more parts to wash, but none of them are hard to clean, and there is no motor base to wipe down. If you mill food only a few times a year, the extra washing is a small cost for a much smoother sauce.
FAQ
Can a blender replace a food mill for tomato sauce?
A blender can puree cooked tomatoes, but it cannot remove the skins and seeds, so the sauce will need straining or peeling first. A food mill removes skins and seeds while it purees, so it gives a smoother sauce with less prep work.
Can a food mill make smoothies?
No, a food mill only handles cooked, soft food, and it cannot crush ice or blend frozen fruit. Smoothies need a blender, which chops raw and frozen ingredients into a uniform drink.
Do I need both a food mill and a blender?
Many cooks keep both, because the tools do different jobs. The blender covers daily smoothies, soups, and frozen drinks, while the mill covers seasonal tomato sauce, applesauce, and mashed potatoes where a smooth, seed-free texture matters.
Which is easier to clean, a food mill or a blender?
A blender jar rinses out quickly and many jars are dishwasher safe, so the blender is faster to clean after a single batch. A food mill has more parts to wash by hand, but the parts are simple and none of them need special care.
Bottom Line
A food mill and a blender are not rivals, they are partners with different strengths. The mill wins on texture and separation: it turns whole cooked tomatoes and apples into smooth, seed-free sauce with no peeling. The blender wins on speed and range: it crushes ice, blends raw vegetables, and finishes a smoothie in under a minute. If your cooking centers on seasonal sauces and canning, put a mill like the Mirro Foley or the GEFU Flotte Lotte in the kitchen first. If your cooking centers on daily smoothies and quick soups, put a blender like the Blendtec Classic 575, the KitchenAid Diamond KSB1575, or the Ninja BN801 system on the counter first. Cooks who do both will use both, and each one earns its place.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!