⏱ 10 min read  ·  ✅ Updated Nov 2026

A yogurt maker and an ice cream maker look like cousins on the countertop. Both turn a liquid base into a chilled or cultured treat, both run with little attention, and both promise homemade versions of foods that cost more at the store. The resemblance ends there. One grows live cultures at a gentle warmth for hours, and the other freezes and churns a base into a scoopable dessert in under an hour. Buying the wrong one means a machine that sits unused while the treat you actually want still comes from a tub.

Our top pick: Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker. Runner-up: Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic Compressor Ice Cream Maker.

This guide compares the two kinds of machines directly, then looks at three ice cream makers and two yogurt makers with the details that matter: capacity, cooling or heating method, controls, and cleanup. Use it to match the machine to the food your household eats most often.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases made through links in this article.

What Each Machine Does

A yogurt maker holds milk and a spoonful of live culture at a steady warm temperature, usually for 8 to 12 hours, while bacteria turn lactose into lactic acid and the milk thickens into yogurt. Some models then cool the finished yogurt automatically so it does not keep culturing. The result is plain or flavored yogurt, and with a strainer it becomes thick Greek-style yogurt. The machine never freezes anything. Its job is patience and temperature control.

An ice cream maker does the opposite job. It chills a sweetened cream or fruit base while a paddle churns it, folding in air and breaking up ice crystals so the finished dessert scoops smoothly. Compressor models freeze the bowl themselves, so a batch can begin the moment the base is ready. Freezer-bowl models need the bowl chilled in a freezer for a full day before churning.

The practical difference is the calendar. Yogurt is a slow food that rewards a routine: warm milk in the evening, fresh yogurt in the morning. Ice cream is a fast treat: mix a base, churn it, and serve it the same afternoon. A household that eats yogurt every day gets more use from a yogurt maker, while a household that serves dessert on weekends gets more use from an ice cream maker.

The Ice Cream Maker Side: Three Picks

1. Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

The Cuisinart ICE-100 is the workhorse of this comparison. A built-in commercial-quality compressor freezes the bowl, so there is no bowl to chill in advance and a second batch can follow the first without a day of waiting. The 1.5-quart capacity suits a family batch, and the machine ships with two paddles: one for ice cream and one for gelato and sorbet. A 60-minute countdown timer runs the churn, and a 10-minute Keep Cool cycle holds the finished dessert at serving temperature when nobody is ready to eat yet.

The brushed stainless housing fits a modern kitchen, and the three-year limited warranty is longer than most rivals in this group. At roughly 17 inches long, it needs a real patch of counter, and it is heavy enough that most owners give it a permanent home rather than lifting it in and out of a cabinet.

Specs: Capacity: 1.5 quarts | Freezing: Built-in compressor, no pre-freezing | Paddles: Ice cream paddle and gelato paddle | Timer: 60-minute countdown with 10-minute Keep Cool | Warranty: Limited 3-year | Dimensions: 16.73 x 12 x 9.33 inches | ASIN: B006UKLUFS

2. Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic Compressor Ice Cream Maker

The Whynter ICM-15LS takes the compressor idea and adds a digital brain. Its 1.6-quart stainless bowl churns ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and frozen yogurt with a built-in compressor, an LCD display, and a timer, so the machine handles both freezing and churning without a pre-chilled bowl. An extended cooling function keeps the finished dessert from melting if serving runs late, and a motor protection function pauses the motor when the mixture turns solid, which guards the machine during thick batches.

Power draw is 150 watts, and the cooling range reaches down to about minus 31 degrees Fahrenheit, which is colder than most home freezers need for a scoopable texture. The removable aluminum bowl and BPA-free churn blade lift out for washing, and the package includes a scoop. At 27 pounds it is a substantial machine, but the capacity and the hands-off cooling make it a strong pick for a household that churns large batches and wants the machine to manage the timing.

Specs: Capacity: 1.6 quarts | Freezing: Built-in compressor, no pre-freezing | Display: LCD digital display with timer | Cooling range: 0 to minus 31 degrees Fahrenheit | Power: 150 watts | Weight: 27 pounds | Warranty: 1-year limited | ASIN: B004N8KD5M

3. Breville Smart Scoop BCI600XL Ice Cream Maker

The Breville Smart Scoop is the most controlled machine in this group. Twelve hardness settings cover sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream, and the machine senses the firmness of the mixture and adjusts as it churns. Automatic and manual modes let the cook either pick a setting and walk away or steer the churn by hand. A pre-cool function chills the bowl before the base goes in, and the keep-cool function holds a finished batch at serving temperature for up to three hours, which is the longest hold in this comparison.

The bowl holds 1.1 quarts, smaller than the Cuisinart and Whynter picks, so it suits a household that makes modest batches rather than party quantities. The brushed stainless body measures about 16.2 by 7.2 by 10.8 inches, a slim footprint for a compressor machine, and the paddle and lid are top-rack dishwasher safe while the bowl washes by hand.

Specs: Capacity: 1.1 quarts | Freezing: Built-in compressor with pre-cool | Hardness settings: 12, for sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream | Operation: Automatic and manual modes | Keep cool: Up to 3 hours | Dimensions: 16.2 x 7.2 x 10.8 inches | ASIN: B009OZ62IG

The Yogurt Maker Side: Two Picks

4. Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker with Automatic Cooling

The Cuisinart CYM-100 is the yogurt maker for a household that makes big batches and does not want to watch the clock. Its 1.5-liter jar holds about 50 ounces of yogurt in a single batch, and the electronic controls set the fermenting time, then switch automatically to cooling when the time is up. That cooling step matters: without it, yogurt left in a warm machine keeps culturing and turns sharper than planned, so a batch finished overnight is still mild in the morning.

The jar is BPA-free plastic with stainless steel accents on the housing, and the machine runs on standard 120-volt power. At about 10 by 7 by 10 inches and 7 pounds, it is smaller than any compressor ice cream maker here, and it stores easily in a cabinet between batches.

Specs: Capacity: 1.5 liters, about 50 ounces | Cooling: Automatic cooling after fermenting | Controls: Electronic time control with display | Container: BPA-free plastic jar | Power: 120 volts | Dimensions: 10 x 7 x 10 inches | Weight: 7 pounds | ASIN: B00ARSC1MK

5. Euro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker

The Euro Cuisine YM80 takes the opposite approach to the Cuisinart: seven individual 6-ounce glass jars instead of one large container. Each jar can hold a different flavor, so one batch can cover plain yogurt for cooking, a fruit version for breakfast, and a sweetened jar for dessert. The glass jars are easy to wash, and they go straight to the table or the fridge with a lid, so there is no second container to fill.

The machine itself is compact and white, with a clear dome lid that shows the jars inside. Its simple controls set the fermenting time, and the jars sit in a heated base that holds a steady warmth for the whole cycle.

Specs: Capacity: Seven 6-ounce glass jars | Controls: Timer with on and off switch | Jars: Glass with lids | Design: Clear dome lid, compact white housing | Model: YM80 | ASIN: B000EX16RY

Side-by-Side Differences That Decide It

Batch size is the first split. The ice cream makers here hold 1.1 to 1.6 quarts per batch, and a batch is ready in 30 to 60 minutes. The yogurt makers hold 1.5 liters in one jar or seven small jars, and a batch takes 8 to 12 hours. Ice cream serves a crowd tonight; yogurt feeds a household all week.

Effort is the second split. An ice cream maker asks for a base to be mixed and chilled, then churns it with little attention. A yogurt maker asks for milk to be heated, cooled to a warm temperature, mixed with culture, and then left alone for hours. The yogurt routine has more steps before the machine takes over, but the machine itself does less: it only holds warmth, while the ice cream maker freezes, churns, and times everything.

Counter space and storage form the third split. Compressor ice cream makers are the biggest machines here, heavy and wide, and most owners leave them out permanently. Yogurt makers are smaller and lighter, and the Euro Cuisine jars store inside the machine. If counter space is tight, a yogurt maker is far easier to live with.

Cleanup is the fourth split. Ice cream maker bowls, paddles, and lids wash after every batch, and a compressor bowl needs hand washing. Yogurt maker jars and containers are simpler: glass jars rinse clean, and the Cuisinart jar washes in the sink.

Cost of running is the fifth split. A yogurt maker uses little power and turns a jug of milk into a week of yogurt, which is one of the cheapest upgrades in the kitchen. An ice cream maker uses more power per batch and needs cream, sugar, and flavorings, so each batch costs more than a tub of yogurt.

How to Choose

Pick an ice cream maker if dessert is the goal. A household that serves ice cream, gelato, or sorbet on weekends, hosts summer gatherings, or wants frozen yogurt with chosen flavors will use a compressor machine often. Choose the Cuisinart ICE-100 for back-to-back batches and two paddles, the Whynter ICM-15LS for the largest capacity and digital controls, or the Breville Smart Scoop for exact hardness settings and a long keep-cool window.

Pick a yogurt maker if yogurt is a daily food. A household that eats yogurt at breakfast, packs it in lunches, or cooks with it will get more value from a machine that cultures a fresh batch overnight. Choose the Cuisinart CYM-100 for one large jar and automatic cooling, or the Euro Cuisine YM80 for seven single-serving glass jars in different flavors.

A household that wants both foods should buy the machine for the food it eats more often and add the other later. The two machines do not replace each other: a yogurt maker cannot freeze ice cream, and an ice cream maker cannot culture yogurt.

FAQ

Can a yogurt maker also make frozen yogurt?
A yogurt maker cultures fresh yogurt, and that yogurt can go into an ice cream maker to become frozen yogurt, but the yogurt maker itself cannot freeze anything. Frozen yogurt needs a machine with a compressor or a pre-frozen bowl.

Can an ice cream maker make yogurt?
No. An ice cream maker freezes and churns, while yogurt needs hours of steady gentle warmth for cultures to grow. The two machines work in opposite temperature ranges, so neither can do the other’s job.

How long does homemade yogurt keep in the fridge?
Homemade yogurt keeps about one to two weeks in a sealed container in the fridge. Plain yogurt lasts longer than flavored yogurt, and a clean spoon and a tight lid help it stay fresh for the full span.

Do compressor ice cream makers need a pre-frozen bowl?
No. A compressor ice cream maker freezes its own bowl, so a batch can begin as soon as the base is mixed and chilled. Freezer-bowl models are the ones that need the bowl chilled for a full day before churning.

The Bottom Line

A yogurt maker and an ice cream maker serve different appetites. The yogurt maker is a quiet daily tool that turns milk into a week of fresh yogurt with little effort, while the ice cream maker is a weekend machine that turns cream and fruit into dessert in under an hour. Match the machine to the food your household eats most, check the capacity and the counter space it needs, and the choice makes itself.