⏱ 9 min read  ·  ✅ Updated Nov 2026

A good baking pan does more than hold batter. It shapes how heat reaches the cake, how evenly the edges brown, and how cleanly a finished bake leaves the pan. The wrong pan can leave a sheet cake pale in the middle and dark at the corners, or a brownie that clings to the sides no matter how well you grease it.

Our top pick: Wilton Platinum Non-Stick 13 by 9 Inch Oblong Baking Pan. Runner-up: Farberware Nonstick Bakeware 9 by 13 Inch Rectangular Cake Pan.

This guide compares five baking pans that cover the shapes most home bakers reach for again and again: the classic 9 by 13 inch rectangle, a square pan for smaller batches, and a round pan for layer cakes. Each pick below is a distinct model with its own material, coating, and depth, so you can match the pan to the bakes you make most.

How to Choose a Baking Pan

Match the shape to the bake

Rectangular 9 by 13 inch pans are the workhorses of the baking shelf. They suit sheet cakes, brownies, blondies, bar cookies, and slab-style bakes that feed a crowd. A square 9 inch pan holds about half the batter of a 9 by 13 inch pan, which makes it a better fit for smaller households and for recipes written for an 8 or 9 inch square. A round 9 inch pan is the classic choice for layer cakes, and two of them together give you a standard two-layer cake.

Look at the material

Heavy-gauge steel and aluminized steel heat quickly and evenly, and they hold their shape in a hot oven. Pure aluminum is lighter and conducts heat very well, though it can flex if the gauge is thin. Stainless steel resists rust and keeps a bright finish, but it usually needs a nonstick coating to release cakes cleanly.

Check the coating and the depth

A good nonstick coating lets a cake release in one piece and makes cleanup much easier. Look for a coating that is described as scratch resistant and safe for use with wooden or silicone tools, and keep metal utensils away from it. Depth matters too. A pan that is 2 inches deep or more gives batter room to rise without spilling over the rim, while a shallow pan suits brownies and bar cookies that do not rise much.

Think about cleanup and storage

Dishwasher-safe pans save time, but hand washing with a soft sponge keeps a nonstick coating in good condition for longer. Pans with rolled or reinforced rims resist warping and give you a solid grip with oven mitts.

1. Wilton Platinum Non-Stick 13 by 9 Inch Oblong Baking Pan

The Wilton Platinum oblong pan is the most versatile pick in this guide. Its 13 by 9 inch size is the standard rectangle for sheet cakes, brownies, and bar cookies, and its stainless steel body gives it a sturdy feel that lighter steel pans do not match. The nonstick surface is made without PFAS, and the pan is built for everyday baking rather than occasional use.

Heat spreads evenly across the flat base, so a sheet cake bakes to a level top instead of doming in the middle. The straight sides and sharp corners give cakes clean edges, which matters when you cut brownies or bars into neat squares. The pan is deep enough for a generous layer of batter, and the rim is easy to grip with oven mitts when the pan is full and hot.

Specs

  • Size: 13 by 9 inches
  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Coating: Nonstick, made without PFAS
  • Care: Hand wash recommended
  • Best for: Sheet cakes, brownies, and bar cookies

2. Farberware Nonstick Bakeware 9 by 13 Inch Rectangular Cake Pan

The Farberware rectangular cake pan is a classic nonstick 9 by 13 inch pan in gray. It is the kind of pan that earns its place through steady, reliable baking rather than any single flashy feature. The heavy-gauge steel body heats evenly, and the nonstick coating releases cakes and brownies without a fight.

This pan suits bakers who want a straightforward rectangle that works the first time and the fiftieth time. The surface browns the edges of a sheet cake to a light golden color while the center stays moist, and a batch of brownies lifts out in clean squares when the pan is lined with parchment. Cleanup is simple: a soft sponge and warm water take care of most residue, and the nonstick surface means you rarely need to scrub. Keep metal utensils out of the pan and let it cool before washing, and the coating will keep releasing cakes cleanly for a long time.

Specs

  • Size: 9 by 13 inches
  • Material: Heavy-gauge steel
  • Coating: Nonstick
  • Color: Gray
  • Care: Hand wash recommended
  • Best for: Sheet cakes, brownies, and casseroles

3. Chicago Metallic Professional Slice Solutions Brownie Pan, 9 by 13 Inches

The Chicago Metallic Slice Solutions brownie pan takes a different approach to the 9 by 13 inch rectangle. It comes with a divider that splits the pan into neat portions as the brownies bake, so every piece comes out the same size with clean edges. If you have ever cut a tray of brownies into uneven pieces, this pan solves that problem at the source.

The inner baking surface measures 9 by 13 inches at the rim, with walls about 1.5 inches deep. The pan is made from heavy-gauge steel with a nonstick coating, and the dark gray finish helps the edges of brownies develop a light crust. The divider lifts out after baking, and the brownies release in even bars without the ragged edges that a knife can leave behind.

Beyond brownies, the pan works well for blondies, lemon bars, and other bar cookies that benefit from even portions. The divider is removable, so the pan also works as a plain 9 by 13 inch pan when you want a single uncut slab.

Specs

  • Size: 9 by 13 inches inside at the rim, 1.5 inches deep
  • Material: Heavy-gauge steel
  • Coating: Nonstick
  • Model: 26740
  • Color: Dark gray
  • Best for: Brownies, blondies, and bar cookies in even portions

4. Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware 9-Inch Square Cake Pan

The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic square cake pan is the smaller-batch pick in this guide. At 9 inches square, it holds about half the batter of a 9 by 13 inch pan, which makes it a better match for recipes written for a square pan and for households that do not need a full sheet cake every time. The silver nonstick surface is part of the Chef’s Classic line, a long-running bakeware family known for steady, even heating.

Square pans bake a little differently from rectangles. The corners are closer to the center, so the whole cake bakes more evenly and the edges do not dry out before the middle is done. This pan gives a single-layer cake a neat, even crumb, and it is a good size for coffee cake, a small chocolate cake, or a batch of brownies that will not linger for days.

The pan is solid and well balanced, with a rim that is easy to hold. The nonstick coating releases cakes cleanly when the pan is greased lightly, and cleanup takes only a few minutes with a soft sponge.

Specs

  • Size: 9 by 9 inches
  • Material: Heavy-gauge steel
  • Coating: Nonstick
  • Color: Silver
  • Model: AMB-9SCK
  • Best for: Single-layer cakes, coffee cake, and small-batch brownies

5. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Round Cake Pan, 9 Inch

The OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro round cake pan is the layer-cake pick in this guide. A 9 inch round pan is the standard size for a two-layer cake, and this one is built from heavy-gauge aluminized steel with a ceramic-reinforced nonstick coating that releases sponge cakes cleanly. The pan holds about 8 cups of batter, which is enough for a full layer.

Round pans need even heat more than any other shape, because a layer cake shows every flaw. A pan that heats unevenly leaves one side of the layer higher than the other, and a layer that sticks tears when you turn it out. The OXO pan spreads heat evenly across the base, and the nonstick surface helps the layer drop out in one piece when the pan is greased and lined with a round of parchment.

The pan has a comfortable weight and a rim that is easy to grip. It pairs well with a second identical pan for two-layer cakes, and it also works on its own for a single-layer cake, a coffee cake, or a deep-dish fruit dessert.

Specs

  • Size: 9 inches in diameter
  • Material: Heavy-gauge aluminized steel
  • Coating: Nonstick Pro, ceramic-reinforced
  • Capacity: About 8 cups
  • Model: 11160100
  • Best for: Layer cakes, single-layer cakes, and fruit desserts

Baking Pans at a Glance

Pan Shape Size Material
Wilton Platinum Oblong Rectangle 13 by 9 inches Stainless steel, nonstick
Farberware Rectangular Rectangle 9 by 13 inches Steel, nonstick
Chicago Metallic Slice Solutions Rectangle with divider 9 by 13 inches Steel, nonstick
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Square Square 9 by 9 inches Steel, nonstick
OXO Non-Stick Pro Round Round 9 inches Aluminized steel, nonstick

Which Pan Fits Your Bake

For a sheet cake that feeds a crowd, either 9 by 13 inch rectangle works well. Choose the Wilton Platinum pan if you want a stainless steel body and a PFAS-free coating, and choose the Farberware pan if you want a classic nonstick rectangle at a simpler build. For brownies that need to come out in even portions, the Chicago Metallic pan with its divider is the clear pick.

For a smaller cake, the Cuisinart square pan is the better fit. It bakes a single layer evenly and suits recipes written for a 9 inch square. For a two-layer cake, buy two OXO round pans. Their even heat and clean release give you layers that stack neatly without trimming.

Care Tips for Baking Pans

Grease the pan lightly and line the base with parchment for the cleanest release, even on a nonstick pan. Let the pan cool for ten to fifteen minutes before turning a cake out, so the crumb sets and the cake holds its shape. Wash pans by hand with a soft sponge and mild soap, and dry them fully before stacking to keep the coating in good condition. Avoid metal utensils and sharp knives inside the pan, and do not cut a cake while it is still in the pan.

FAQ

What size baking pan is best for a first pan?

A 9 by 13 inch rectangular pan is the best first pan for most bakers. It handles sheet cakes, brownies, bar cookies, and savory bakes, and most recipes written for a crowd call for this size.

Can I use a 9 by 13 inch pan instead of two 9 inch round pans?

You can, but the bake will be thinner and will need less time in the oven. A 9 by 13 inch pan holds more batter than one round pan and less than two, so check the cake early and test the center with a toothpick.

Why does my cake stick to a nonstick pan?

A cake can stick when the pan is not greased, when the coating is worn, or when the cake is turned out too soon. Grease the pan lightly, line the base with parchment, and let the cake cool for ten to fifteen minutes before turning it out.

How do I keep a nonstick coating in good condition?

Hand wash the pan with a soft sponge, avoid metal utensils, and let the pan cool before washing. High heat and harsh scrubbing wear a coating down faster than normal baking does.

The Bottom Line

The best baking pan is the one that matches the bakes you make most. A 9 by 13 inch rectangle covers sheet cakes and brownies, a square pan suits smaller batches, and a round pan is the pick for layer cakes. The Wilton Platinum pan is the most versatile rectangle here, the Chicago Metallic pan is the smartest choice for even brownie portions, and the OXO round pan is the one to buy for layer cakes.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. This disclosure applies to the product links in this guide.